Asylum in Removal Proceedings: Filing the I-589
Asylum in Removal Proceedings: Filing the I-589
Asylum can protect people who fear persecution in their home country, but the process is different when you are already in immigration court. If you are in removal proceedings, asylum is filed with the immigration court and decided by an immigration judge.
Legal Background
Asylum is governed by INA section 208. In removal proceedings, you apply using Form I-589 and present your case at an individual hearing. The judge decides whether you meet the legal definition of a refugee and whether any bars apply.
The One-Year Filing Deadline
Most people must file for asylum within one year of their last arrival in the United States. There are exceptions for changed or extraordinary circumstances, but they require detailed evidence. If you miss the deadline, you may still pursue other forms of protection, but the asylum claim itself can be denied.
How the Process Works in Court
- File Form I-589 with the immigration court. You must also serve DHS with a copy.
- Submit supporting evidence. This includes a personal declaration, country conditions reports, and any records that support your claim.
- Complete biometrics. DHS will schedule fingerprinting and background checks.
- Attend the individual hearing. You will testify, DHS will cross-examine, and the judge will decide the case.
Evidence That Strengthens an Asylum Case
- A detailed personal declaration describing past harm or threats
- Police reports, medical records, or witness statements when available
- Country conditions reports from reputable sources
- Evidence tying the harm to a protected ground (race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group)
Consistency matters. Your testimony should match your written declaration and prior statements.
Common Challenges
- Credibility findings. Inconsistent details can lead to a denial.
- Insufficient evidence. The judge expects detailed and specific facts, not general fear.
- Deadline issues. Late filings require a clear, supported exception.
- Bars to asylum. Certain criminal convictions or prior removals can block eligibility.
Practical Tips
- Start early. Asylum preparation requires careful writing and evidence collection.
- Use certified translations. Non-English documents must be translated and certified.
- Be specific. Judges look for concrete events, dates, and details.
- Prepare for cross-examination. DHS will test your timeline and story.
When to Seek Legal Help
Asylum in removal proceedings is complex and high-stakes. An attorney can help define the legal theory, prepare the declaration, and organize evidence for court.
If you are considering an asylum claim in immigration court, schedule a consultation to evaluate your case.
This post provides general information and is not legal advice. Laws can change, and your facts matter.
Schedule Your Consultation
Immigration consultations available, subject to attorney review.